Furniture
Sofas, dining sets, bedroom suites, accent pieces, and everything in between. From mid-century modern to farmhouse charm — all priced fairly and ready for your home.
Columbus, Indiana's Premier Resale Destination
Your Next Favorite Thing Is Waiting — For a Fraction of the Price
We source, curate, and price-check every item so you walk out with quality furniture, genuine décor, and one-of-a-kind finds — without the retail markup.
10,000+
Unique Items in Stock
Daily
New Arrivals
100%
Customer Satisfaction
About Us
A Store Built on Discovery, Not Markup
Fantastic Finds Resale started with a simple conviction: people deserve access to quality goods without paying full retail. Every piece in our Columbus showroom is hand-selected, inspected, and priced to reflect its true value — not the price tag it came with.
Whether you're furnishing your first apartment, refreshing a room, hunting for a vintage statement piece, or looking for that perfect gift, our floor is stocked with something that will make you stop and say, "I need that."
- Curated selections — every item is inspected before it hits the floor
- Fresh inventory arrives daily — no two visits are the same
- Knowledgeable staff ready to help you find exactly what you need
- Consignment opportunities for local sellers
What We Offer
Everything You Need, Nothing You Don't
Our showroom is divided into curated categories so you can browse with purpose — or wander and wonder.
Home Décor
Lamps, mirrors, rugs, wall art, vases, and seasonal accents. Find the finishing touches that make a house feel like home — without the big-box store price.
Collectibles & Vintage
Antiques, retro pieces, vintage glassware, books, and unique collectibles. Each item has a story — and now it can be part of yours.
Electronics & Appliances
Tested and working televisions, small appliances, audio equipment, and more. Quality electronics at prices that make sense.
Outdoor & Garden
Patio furniture, garden décor, planters, grills, and seasonal outdoor gear. Get your space ready for the fresh air at a fraction of retail.
Consignment
Have quality items gathering dust? We accept consignment on furniture, décor, and collectibles. We handle the selling — you get paid when it moves.
Why Resale
Smart Shopping Is Good for Your Wallet — and the Planet
Save Real Money
Quality pre-owned goods typically run 40–70% below retail. That's not a compromise — that's a strategy. Your budget stretches further, and your home still looks incredible.
Reduce Waste
Every item rehomed is one less thing in a landfill. Resale is one of the simplest ways to shrink your environmental footprint without changing your lifestyle.
Find the Unfindable
Vintage pieces, discontinued styles, solid-wood furniture built to last — resale is where you find the things big-box stores don't carry anymore.
Support Local
Fantastic Finds is a Columbus-based business. Every purchase keeps money in our community and supports local jobs, not distant corporations.
Visit Us
Come See What's New
Our showroom changes constantly — new arrivals land every day, so there's always something you haven't seen before. Stop by and explore at your own pace.
- Address
- 1609 Cottage Ave Ste C
Columbus, IN 47201 - Phone
- (812) 375-4507
- kinseydavid@hotmail.com
- Hours
- Mon – Sat: 10 AM – 6 PM
Sunday: Closed
1609 Cottage Ave Ste C
Columbus, IN 47201
Get in Touch
Have a Question? We're Happy to Help.
Whether you're wondering if we have a specific item, want to drop off consignment, or just want to say hello — reach out anytime.
